Historic player dates
Games tied to Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle, Roger Maris, Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, and other landmark Yankees careers can merit closer research.
← MLB team ticket guides
Bronx baseball history
Sell Old New York Yankees Ticket Stubs
A practical guide for identifying and selling old New York Yankees ticket stubs—from early Yankee Stadium dates through championship seasons and modern milestones.
Send Photos for a Cash OfferWhat makes a Yankees ticket worth researching?
Yankees tickets are often collected as pieces of a particular game, player, championship run, or version of Yankee Stadium—not simply because the team name appears on the stub.
A date that looks ordinary can connect to a debut, milestone, postseason clincher, no-hitter, or a memorable opponent. That is why the date, opponent, seat information, and surviving condition all matter.
We do not value tickets from a team name alone. We research the event and consider what collectors are currently likely to buy.
Types of Yankees tickets collectors may seek
These are research categories, not a guarantee that every ticket in the category has significant value.
World Series and postseason
Full tickets and stubs from championship runs, decisive games, and unusual postseason matchups are a core Yankees collecting category.
Stadium history
Openers, closers, renovation-era games, and tickets that document the transition between Yankee Stadiums have their own appeal.
Milestones and rare events
Perfect games, no-hitters, record chases, debuts, final appearances, and significant home runs may make an otherwise modest-looking ticket important.
Before you send photos
- ✓Photograph the front and back; printing, turnstile marks, and advertising can help date a ticket.
- ✓Include the printed date, opponent, section, row, and seat when legible.
- ✓Do not trim edges, remove staples, erase writing, or laminate the ticket.
- ✓If the year is uncertain, send nearby programs, scorecards, or envelopes in the same group.
How our offer works
StubHaul is a ticket-stub buyer, not an independent appraisal service. We purchase items for resale.
Any offer reflects expected resale demand, condition, our research, selling costs, and the time required to find a buyer. You are free to accept or decline it.
Read how the process works →Frequently asked questions
Are all old Yankees tickets valuable?
No. Age and the Yankees name help establish interest, but the exact game, player connection, scarcity, completeness, and condition usually matter more.
Do you buy common regular-season Yankees stubs?
Sometimes, especially as part of an organized group or older collection. Send photos and an approximate count so we can evaluate the group efficiently.
Can you identify a Yankees game from a partial ticket?
Often, but not always. A clear front-and-back photo plus any visible date, opponent, gate, section, or price gives us the best chance.
Show us your Yankees tickets
Send clear photos and whatever you know about the collection. No cleaning, grading, or price research is required first.
Research note: This guide is educational and non-exhaustive. Game and date identification is checked against available schedules and event records; when an item cannot be identified confidently, we say so.