Where to Sell Old Ticket Stubs in 2025: Best Options Compared

Comparing Your Options for Selling Ticket Stubs

If you've decided to sell your ticket stubs, you have several options available. Each has its own pros and cons in terms of convenience, speed, price, and effort required. This guide compares the most common selling methods to help you choose the best option for your situation.

Option 1: Sell Directly to a Specialized Buyer

Companies like StubHaul specialize in buying ticket stub collections. The process is simple: you send photos, receive a cash offer, and get paid — often before you even ship your stubs.

Pros: Fast (offers in minutes), easy (no listing or photography required), no fees, payment before shipping (PayPal/Venmo), they handle everything.

Cons: You may get slightly less than if you individually sold rare stubs at auction, since the buyer needs margin. However, for most sellers, the convenience and speed more than make up for this.

Option 2: eBay

eBay is the largest marketplace for ticket stubs, with thousands of listings at any given time.

Pros: Potentially higher prices for individual rare stubs, large buyer audience, auction format can drive up prices for desirable items.

Cons: eBay fees (12-15% of sale price), PayPal/payment processing fees, time-consuming to photograph and list each stub individually, dealing with shipping to multiple buyers, risk of non-paying bidders, returns, and disputes. Selling a large collection on eBay can take months of effort.

Option 3: Auction Houses

Major sports memorabilia auction houses like Heritage Auctions, REA, and SCP Auctions handle high-value ticket stubs.

Pros: Can achieve maximum prices for truly rare, high-value stubs. Professional authentication and cataloging.

Cons: High seller commissions (15-25%), slow (auction cycles can take months), minimum value thresholds (most won't bother with stubs worth less than $100-500), and you wait until after the auction to get paid.

Option 4: Local Dealers and Shows

Sports memorabilia shows and local dealers are another option.

Pros: In-person evaluation, immediate cash payment, no shipping.

Cons: Limited to your geographic area, dealers at shows often offer lower prices due to their own overhead, and you need to transport your collection to the show.

Our Recommendation

For most sellers, selling directly to a specialized buyer like StubHaul offers the best combination of fair pricing, speed, and convenience. You avoid eBay fees, auction house commissions, and the time investment of listing stubs individually. For truly museum-quality, five-figure stubs, a major auction house might maximize your return, but for 99% of collections, a direct sale is the way to go.