How Much Are No-Hitter and Perfect Game Ticket Stubs Worth?

The Rarest Moments in Baseball History

No-hitters and perfect games represent the absolute pinnacle of pitching achievement in baseball. In over 150 years of professional baseball, only about 320 no-hitters and just 24 perfect games have been thrown. The ticket stubs from these games are among the most collectible items in baseball memorabilia, prized for their connection to truly rare athletic achievement.

What makes these ticket stubs so special isn't just their rarity—it's the fact that they represent witnessed history. Every person holding a ticket stub from a perfect game or no-hitter was present for a moment that might not happen again for years, or in some cases, decades. This combination of historical significance and extreme scarcity drives values that can reach thousands of dollars for the right stub.

Perfect Game Stubs: The Holy Grail

With only 24 perfect games in MLB history, stubs from these games are extraordinarily rare. Consider that each perfect game was witnessed by a single stadium of fans on a single day, and most of those fans didn't preserve their stubs. Fifty or even thirty years later, the number of surviving stubs from any given perfect game could be measured in the dozens.

Don Larsen's perfect game in the 1956 World Series remains the crown jewel of perfect game ticket stubs. The only no-hitter and perfect game in World Series history, it combines multiple layers of collectibility: a perfect game, World Series significance, and the legendary Yankees-Dodgers rivalry. Stubs from this game routinely sell for $3,000-$8,000 depending on condition, making it one of the most valuable New York Yankees ticket stubs ever.

More recent perfect games still produce valuable stubs, though values vary significantly based on the pitcher and circumstances. Roy Halladay's 2010 playoff perfect game against the Reds carries premium value ($800-$2,500) due to its postseason context, while regular season perfect games from the 1990s and 2000s typically range from $400-$1,200.

The Perfect Game Drought

The fact that there have been no perfect games since Félix Hernández's achievement in 2012 has created additional collector interest. Every year that passes without a perfect game makes existing stubs scarcer and more valuable. This drought effect has been particularly noticeable in the pricing of stubs from the cluster of perfect games thrown between 2009-2012.

No-Hitter Stubs by Notable Pitchers

No-hitter stubs are more common than perfect game stubs but still highly collectible, especially when thrown by Hall of Fame pitchers or in significant contexts. The most sought-after no-hitter stub collections center around legendary pitchers who threw multiple no-hitters.

Nolan Ryan's Seven No-Hitters

Nolan Ryan's seven no-hitters produced perhaps the most widely collected set of no-hitter stubs in baseball history. His first no-hitter with the Angels in 1973 carries the highest value ($600-$1,500), while his record-setting seventh no-hitter in 1991 at age 44 against the Blue Jays is equally prized ($500-$1,200). Ryan's no-hitter stubs benefit from his status as a pitching icon and the narrative appeal of his longevity.

Sandy Koufax's Dominance

Sandy Koufax's four no-hitters, including his perfect game in 1965, represent some of the most valuable no-hitter stubs from the 1960s. Koufax's perfect game stub can reach $2,000-$4,500, while his other three no-hitter stubs typically sell for $400-$1,000 each. The Brooklyn and LA Dodgers ticket stub market has always been strong, and Koufax stubs represent the premium end of Dodgers collectibles.

Modern No-Hitter Values

Recent no-hitter stubs from active or recently retired stars carry significant value, though typically less than vintage examples. Max Scherzer's two no-hitters in 2015 produced stubs worth $200-$600, while Jordan Zimmermann's 2014 no-hitter—the first in Nationals history—sells for $150-$400.

Combined no-hitters (thrown by multiple pitchers in a single game) produce interesting collectible stubs that document unique team achievements rather than individual brilliance. These typically sell for $75-$300 depending on the teams and era involved.

Context Matters: Postseason and Milestone Games

The context surrounding a no-hitter or perfect game dramatically affects stub values. Postseason no-hitters are extremely rare—Roy Halladay threw the second in MLB history in 2010, with the first coming in 1956. This rarity drives premium pricing for postseason no-hitter stubs.

Similarly, no-hitters that occur during significant seasons or against notable opponents carry additional value. A no-hitter against the Yankees typically sells for more than one against a small-market team, while no-hitters thrown during championship seasons benefit from increased collector interest.

Stadium and Regional Factors

The venue where a no-hitter or perfect game occurred can significantly impact stub values. Games at iconic stadiums like Yankee Stadium, Fenway Park, or Wrigley Field typically command premium prices. Additionally, a pitcher's first career no-hitter at his home stadium often produces the most valuable stubs from his no-hitter collection.

Regional collecting patterns also influence values. A Rangers pitcher's no-hitter stub will typically sell for more in Texas than on the East Coast, while Yankees no-hitter stubs maintain strong national appeal due to the team's widespread fanbase.

Condition and Authentication

Condition plays a crucial role in determining no-hitter and perfect game stub values. These stubs are often kept as souvenirs, but many suffer damage from wallets, scrapbooks, or poor storage over decades. A pristine stub can sell for three to five times more than a damaged example from the same game.

Professional grading through PSA has become increasingly important for high-value no-hitter and perfect game stubs. A PSA 8 or higher grade provides authenticity verification and condition certification that serious collectors demand. For stubs potentially worth over $500, professional grading is often worth the investment.

Storage and Preservation Tips

If you own no-hitter or perfect game stubs, proper storage is essential for maintaining value. Keep stubs in acid-free holders, away from direct sunlight, and in stable temperature environments. Avoid lamination, tape, or any permanent alterations that could damage the stub or reduce its collectibility.

Investment Potential and Market Trends

No-hitter and perfect game stubs have shown strong appreciation over the past decade, particularly for games from the 1950s-1980s. The combination of increasing collector interest and natural attrition of surviving stubs creates upward pressure on values.

Perfect game stubs have outperformed no-hitter stubs in terms of percentage gains, largely due to their extreme rarity. As the time between perfect games continues to grow, this trend is likely to continue. Even stubs from less famous perfect games have doubled or tripled in value over the past 15 years.

Valuation Factors and Price Ranges

The value of a no-hitter or perfect game stub depends on several key factors: the pitcher's fame and Hall of Fame status, the era when the game occurred, the game context (regular season vs. postseason), the opposing team, and the stub's condition.

Perfect game stubs from Hall of Fame pitchers in the 1950s-1960s represent the highest tier, potentially worth $2,000-$8,000 in excellent condition. Modern perfect game stubs from the 1990s-2010s typically range from $400-$1,500, while no-hitter stubs from famous pitchers sell for $300-$1,500 depending on the specific game and condition.

Even no-hitter stubs from lesser-known pitchers maintain collector interest, typically selling for $50-$300. The key principle is that all no-hitter and perfect game stubs have inherent collectible value—the question is simply the degree based on the factors mentioned above.

Turn Your Historic Stubs Into Cash

If you attended a no-hitter or perfect game and preserved your ticket stub, you're holding a piece of baseball history that collectors actively seek. These stubs are always in demand from serious collectors who understand their historical significance and rarity.

At StubHaul, we specialize in purchasing high-value ticket stubs from collectors and fans who want to convert their memorabilia into cash. Our team of experts understands the no-hitter and perfect game stub market and can provide you with a fair, competitive offer based on current market values.

Don't let your historic ticket stubs sit in a drawer—contact StubHaul today for a free, no-obligation appraisal. We make the selling process simple and secure, with prompt payment and professional service. Whether you have a single perfect game stub or a collection of no-hitter tickets, we're interested in making you a cash offer that reflects the true value of your baseball history.