The Most Valuable New York Yankees Ticket Stubs Ever

Why Yankees Ticket Stubs Are Baseball's Most Collectible

The New York Yankees are the most storied franchise in American sports. With 27 World Series championships, a roster of legendary players that reads like a baseball Hall of Fame roll call, and a home ballpark — Yankee Stadium — that has been called "The House That Ruth Built," Yankees memorabilia occupies a tier of its own in the collecting world.

Yankees ticket stubs are particularly sought after because of the sheer volume of historic moments that have occurred while wearing pinstripes. From Babe Ruth's legendary home runs to Lou Gehrig's farewell speech, from Joe DiMaggio's hitting streak to Derek Jeter's final game, the franchise has produced an unmatched catalog of memorable events.

The Most Valuable Yankees Stubs by Era

The Ruth-Gehrig Era (1920s-1930s)

Ticket stubs from the Ruth and Gehrig years are the most valuable Yankees collectibles. Any stub from the original Yankee Stadium during this era carries significant value due to age and scarcity alone. Stubs from World Series games during the Yankees' dynasty years of the late 1920s and early 1930s can command four-figure prices even in modest condition.

Particularly prized are stubs from Babe Ruth milestone games — his 60th home run in 1927, World Series appearances, and games at the original Yankee Stadium. Lou Gehrig's farewell game on July 4, 1939, produced stubs that are among the most emotionally resonant in all of sports memorabilia.

The DiMaggio-Mantle Era (1940s-1960s)

Joe DiMaggio's 56-game hitting streak in 1941 is one of baseball's most unbreakable records. Stubs from games during the streak are exceptionally valuable, with later games in the streak worth more than earlier ones. Mickey Mantle's incredible career produced numerous collectible stubs, including his 500th home run game and World Series performances.

This era also encompasses the Yankees' unprecedented run of five consecutive World Series titles from 1949-1953, making stubs from those Fall Classic games highly desirable to collectors.

The Jeter Era (1990s-2014)

Derek Jeter's debut, his 3,000th hit, and his final game at Yankee Stadium in 2014 all produced stubs with strong and growing collector value. The 1996 World Series — the beginning of the modern Yankees dynasty — remains a popular collecting target.

Stubs from the final game at the old Yankee Stadium in 2008 and the first game at the new stadium in 2009 are also prized transitional pieces.

What Your Yankees Stubs Could Be Worth

Yankees ticket stub values range enormously based on the specific game, era, and condition. Pre-war World Series stubs can be worth $500-$5,000+, while modern regular season stubs might range from $5-$50. The key is having stubs from significant games or significant moments in Yankees history. If you have Yankees stubs and want to know their value, the best approach is a professional appraisal. StubHaul specializes in evaluating Yankees and other baseball ticket stubs — send us photos for a free, no-obligation cash offer.