The 10 Most Valuable NFL Game Ticket Stubs of All Time

Football's Most Prized Ticket Stubs

Across more than a century of professional football, certain games have achieved legendary status — and their ticket stubs have become some of the most valuable collectibles in sports. These aren't just expensive pieces of paper; they're physical connections to the moments that defined the sport.

The Most Valuable NFL Game Stubs

Super Bowl I (1967) sits atop the list for obvious reasons — it's the first, it's rare, and it's the foundational event of modern football. But beyond the Super Bowl, several regular season and playoff games produce stubs of extraordinary value.

The 1958 NFL Championship Game ("Greatest Game Ever Played"), the 1967 Ice Bowl, the Immaculate Reception game (1972), and the Tuck Rule Game (2002) are all examples of games whose stubs command premium prices well beyond what a "typical" game from the same era would fetch.

What elevates a game's stub value beyond the norm is usually a combination of factors: a dramatic, iconic play; championship stakes; legendary players; and a moment that resonates in football's collective memory decades later.

Beyond the Obvious

Some unexpectedly valuable game stubs include the first regular season MNF game (1970), the "Miracle at the Meadowlands" (1978), the "Epic in Miami" (1982 AFC Divisional Playoff), and the "Minneapolis Miracle" (2018 NFC Divisional Playoff). The value of these stubs reflects the enduring power of the moments they represent.

If you have stubs from memorable NFL games, StubHaul can evaluate their current market value and make a competitive cash offer.