The 15 Most Valuable Baseball Ticket Stubs of All Time

The Most Coveted Baseball Ticket Stubs

Baseball has produced more collectible ticket stubs than any other sport. With over a century of professional play, thousands of historic moments have been documented by the humble ticket stub — a piece of paper that granted admission to a game that would go down in history.

For collectors, certain baseball ticket stubs represent the holy grail of sports memorabilia. These stubs command premium prices at auction and through private sales, with the rarest examples trading for thousands of dollars. Understanding which stubs are most valuable can help you evaluate your own collection.

What Makes a Baseball Stub Valuable?

The value of a baseball ticket stub comes down to a combination of factors: the significance of the game, the rarity of surviving stubs, the condition of the piece, and current collector demand. A stub from a routine mid-season game in 1985 might be worth a few dollars, while a stub from a World Series Game 7 from the same decade could be worth hundreds.

The most valuable stubs almost always come from games where something historic happened — a record was broken, a perfect game was thrown, a dynasty was born, or a legendary player reached a career milestone.

Early World Series Stubs

World Series stubs from the early 1900s through the 1940s are among the most valuable baseball collectibles in existence. The first World Series was played in 1903, and surviving stubs from those early Fall Classics are extraordinarily rare. Even stubs from the 1920s and 1930s can command four-figure prices in good condition.

Perfect Game and No-Hitter Stubs

Only 24 perfect games have been thrown in MLB history, making stubs from these games incredibly rare and valuable. No-hitter stubs also carry premiums, particularly from famous pitchers like Nolan Ryan (who threw seven no-hitters) and Sandy Koufax.

Milestone and Record-Breaking Game Stubs

Stubs from games where major records were broken are always in demand. Hank Aaron's 715th home run, Cal Ripken Jr.'s consecutive games record, and Pete Rose's all-time hits record are examples of games whose stubs carry significant premiums.

Final Game Stubs from Historic Ballparks

When legendary ballparks close their doors for the last time, the ticket stubs from those final games become instant collectibles. Stubs from the final games at Ebbets Field, the Polo Grounds, old Yankee Stadium, Comiskey Park, and Tiger Stadium are all highly sought after.

How to Determine Your Stub's Value

If you have baseball ticket stubs and want to know what they're worth, the best approach is to have them evaluated by a knowledgeable buyer who understands the market. At StubHaul, we offer free, no-obligation appraisals — just send us photos of your stubs and we'll tell you what they're worth and make a cash offer if you're interested in selling.

Don't assume your stubs aren't valuable just because they're from regular season games. Many factors beyond the obvious can affect value, including the teams involved, the players who participated, and whether anything significant happened during the game that you might not even remember.